Ijraset Journal For Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology
Authors: Jahanvi Mishra, Dr Abhishek Verma
DOI Link: https://doi.org/10.22214/ijraset.2024.59049
Certificate: View Certificate
India has undergone significant economic growth and has undertaken multiple development programs. This article explores the complex relationship between India\'s economic aspirations and its obligations towards the environment, emphasizing the crucial importance of environmental diplomacy in managing these intricacies. The article explains how environmental diplomacy may play a crucial role in defining India\'s climate trajectory, while also promoting economic growth and sustainable development.
I. INTRODUCTION
India has had strong economic growth since 2014, characterized by initiatives such as "Make in India" and "Digital India," which have placed it among the economies that are growing the fastest. These endeavors enhance the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), entice foreign investment, and stimulate the generation of employment opportunities. Nevertheless, the swift advancement of society presents environmental obstacles, such pollution and deforestation, which pose threats to both the public's health and diversity. Ensuring a harmonious equilibrium between growth and sustainability is crucial, as uncontrolled expansion has the potential to inflict damage upon environments and future generations. Environmental diplomacy plays a vital role in tackling these difficulties, enabling India to engage in negotiations and champion global environmental preservation while simultaneously fostering economic growth. In the end, it promotes a future that is both environmentally sustainable and able to withstand challenges, despite the conflicts between economic expansion and protecting the environment.
II. RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
III. LITERATURE REVIEW
IV. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This study aims to scrutinize India's environmental predicaments amidst its swift economic advancement and the repercussions of its economic strategies on the environment. The methodology involves gathering, scrutinizing, and integrating secondary data from reputable sources such as academic journals, government reports, international organizations' publications, and news articles.
This methodology provides a robust framework for comprehensively analyzing India's environmental challenges, economic policies, and diplomatic engagements based on secondary data sources, facilitating a deeper understanding of their intricate interplay in the Indian context.
V. RESEARCH QUESTION
What are the key challenges and opportunities for India to strengthen its environmental diplomacy efforts and leverage them to promote sustainable development and address global environmental challenges?
A. Economic Growth and Environmental Implications
India has implemented various initiatives, including "Make in India," "Digital India," "Smart Cities Mission," and "Skill India," with the goal of promoting industrialization, technological progress, urban development, and the development of human capital. These initiatives aim to bring in foreign investment, promote entrepreneurship, generate employment, and expedite economic growth in the manufacturing, service, and agriculture sectors. The industrialization, urbanization, and intensification of agriculture have resulted in economic growth that has caused emissions, loss of biodiversity, and resource depletion. Urban expansion and the construction of infrastructure invade natural areas, while intensive farming methods deteriorate the fertility of soil and water ecosystems.
The energy industry, which heavily depends on fossil fuels, plays a large role in the production of greenhouse gases, hence worsening the effects of climate change and the resulting consequences, including heat waves, flooding, drought, and severe weather. Swift urbanization results in significant amounts of solid waste, putting pressure on waste disposal infrastructure and leading to environmental contamination.
The environmental challenges pose a significant risk to the well-being and health of humans, as well as the integrity of ecosystems, biodiversity, and the sustainability of natural resources. The pursuit of economic development frequently conflicts with the objectives of sustainability, resulting in the deterioration of land, deforestation, loss of biodiversity, overexploitation of resources, and pollution. Environmental diplomacy plays a vital role in balancing these interests, fostering communication, and discovering mutually advantageous resolutions towards sustainable development and preservation of the environment.
B. India's Environmental Commitments and Policies
India has made a firm commitment to international accords and domestic laws in order to address environmental degradation and promote sustainability. India's endeavors to decrease emissions intensity and enhance renewable energy sources are directed by the Paris Agreement, which also includes afforestation activities aimed at establishing carbon sinks. India incorporates the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) into its national development plan. India has implemented the National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC) domestically since 2008. This plan has prioritized missions such as solar energy and sustainable agriculture. The Clean India Mission, initiated in 2014, aims to achieve widespread sanitation and efficient waste management. The National Green Tribunal (NGT), founded in 2010, deals with environmental preservation through specialized legal decision-making. India's objective is to achieve a renewable energy capacity of 175 GW by 2022, with a focus on providing incentives for solar and wind power. The Compensatory Afforestation Fund Act and Green India Mission are initiatives that enhance afforestation and forest conservation efforts, thereby reducing the adverse effects of climate change.
C. India's Role in Negotiating Specific Clauses within the Paris Agreement
India's significant contribution to the development of the Paris Agreement illustrates its dedication to achieving a harmonious balance between economic progress and environmental preservation. India, as a nation in the process of development, has supported the adoption of fair concepts such as shared yet differentiated responsibilities (CBDR), with a focus on highlighting the historical emissions of rich countries. The argument was made in favor of equitably distributing the responsibility for reducing emissions and providing assistance to underdeveloped countries in terms of technology and financial resources. India emphasized the importance of achieving sustainable development while also reducing emissions, with the goal of lifting millions of people out of poverty. During the negotiations inside the Paris Agreement, India emphasized the importance of technological move, capacity-building, and financial aid in order to transition to low-carbon economies while still preserving economic growth. India emphasized the need for measures that provide sufficient financial assistance for climate action, advocating for a mobilization of $100 billion per year by 2020 and ongoing efforts beyond 2025. India's endeavors highlighted its resolve to tackle climate change while also promoting its socioeconomic objectives.
D. Examples of India's Advocacy for Environmental Considerations in International Trade Agreements
India's support for including environmental concerns into international trade agreements demonstrates its acknowledgment of the interdependence of commerce, economic progress, and environmental durability. India, a fast-expanding economy with a vast and varied population, has been actively involved in drafting trade agreements that foster economic progress while also addressing environmental issues.
An illustrative instance of India's support for environmental concerns in trade agreements is its position on intellectual property (IPR) pertaining to clean technologies. India has repeatedly advocated for rules that protect its capacity to obtain and employ clean technologies without being unduly constrained by onerous intellectual property regulations. India seeks to promote the widespread use of clean technologies needed for transition to a low-carbon economy by calling for flexibilities under intellectual property rights (IPR), such as obligatory licensing and technology transfer.
In addition, India has strongly advocated for the concept of ecological responsibility in trade agreements by promoting sustainable agricultural methods. India has prioritized the preservation of environmental resources and the promotion of sustainable farming techniques in discussions like the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) to guarantee food security and support rural lives. India seeks to achieve a balance between agricultural trade and environmental sustainability by promoting methods that prevent environmental deterioration, such as sustainable land utilization and biodiversity conservation.
India's trade agreements frequently advance sustainable development and improving society by facilitating transfer of technology, capacity-building, and financial aid in Africa. This promotes inclusive growth, which is advantageous for the world's ecology and economy.
VI. TRENDS IN ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATORS
These tendencies depict a worrisome image. The declining water and air quality provide significant health hazards to the people, while deforestation damages ecosystems and undermines India’s capacity to cope with a changing climate.
VII. ECONOMIC COSTS OF ENVIRONMENTAL DEGRADATION
Indian environmental issues are costly.
Healthcare Costs: India's healthcare system is heavily impacted by air pollution-related diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), asthma, lung cancer, and heart disease. According to research published in The Lancet in 2020, the economic impact of pollution in the air in India is predicted to be over $150 billion per year, with a significant amount of this cost attributed to healthcare bills.
Water Scarcity: Water shortages brought on by pollution and depletion affect people, businesses, and agriculture. By 2050, water shortage might cost India 6% of its GDP, resulting in hundreds of billions of dollars in economic losses, according to the World Bank [^4].
Loss of Ecosystem Services: Deforestation and habitat loss interrupt key ecosystem functions including purification of water, control of floods, pollination process, and carbon sequestration. These losses cost fishing, farming, and tourism. In 2018, Nature Sustainability research indicated that India loses $53 billion yearly owing to declining pollination services [^5]. Environmental protection is essential due to these economic implications. Sustainable development policies that promote clean air, water, and ecosystems can boost economic growth without harming the environment.
VIII. CASE STUDIES: ENVIRONMENTAL DIPLOMACY IN ACTION
Environmental diplomacy can address these global issues. India led two successful initiatives:
The International Solar Alliance (ISA), founded by India in 2015, promotes solar energy adoption by over 100 nations. The ISA has raised over $1 billion for solar projects as of 2023 and expects to generate 1,000 GW of solar electricity by 2030. If met, this ambitious goal will cut fossil fuel consumption and greenhouse gas emissions, mitigating climate change.
Measurable Effect: In 2022, the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) reported that ISA member nations increased solar power capacity by 1.5 times compared to non-member nations through 2021 [^6]. This significantly reduces carbon emissions and advances greener energy sources.
South-South Cooperation: The ISA excels at promoting sharing of knowledge & transfer of technology between developing nations. This helps nations with underdeveloped solar industry overcome technological barriers and maximize solar potential.
Economic Innovation: The ISA fosters new finance options to fund developing country solar projects. A 2022 project, known as the "One Sun Declaration," intends to raise $1 trillion in solar energy investments by 2030 [^7].
A. Second Case Study: The Indo-Bhutan Green Grid Project
This India-Bhutan environmental diplomacy is regionally successful. Established in 2016, the endeavor seeks to construct a renewable electricity transmission route.
Environmental diplomacy drives beneficial environmental change, as shown in these case studies. Through international collaboration, India can use its diplomatic might and share its expertise to promote sustainable practices.
B. The Challenge of Balancing Economic Growth and Environmental Sustainability
India's commitment under the Paris Agreement is to reduce its emissions of greenhouse gases by 30-35% compared to 2005 levels by the year 2030. To accomplish this, substantial expenditures in sustainable energy infrastructure are required, amounting to an estimated $1.4 trillion every year. Nevertheless, India's reliance upon coals for 70% of its electricity, along with influential fossil fuel firms advocating for economic expansion rather than prioritizing environmental objectives, is a significant obstacle. Research conducted in 2023 via Indian Center for Policy Research uncovered the obstruction of more stringent pollution rules for power plants by coal lobby. This report highlights the impact of domestic politics on impeding global environmental obligations.
C. Domestic Politics: Navigating Complexities and Priorities
India's environmental diplomacy policy is influenced by the intricate interplay of internal politics. The government's attitude may be strongly impacted by powerful industries, especially those that largely depend on fossil fuels. As previously stated, the coal business possesses substantial political influence, advocating for policy that prioritize the expansion and employment opportunities within the sector, even if it compromises environmental sustainability.
D. The Balancing Act: Development Needs vs. Climate Action:
Moreover, political factors have the potential to impact international discussions. During the discussions that led to the signing of the Paris Agreement, India, alongside other developing nations, advocated for the notion that "common but differentiated responsibilities". This concept recognizes the historical accountability of industrialized nations for a significant portion of the emission of greenhouse gases and highlights the necessity for them to offer financial and technological support to emerging countries such as India in their shift towards clean energy. This underscores the intricate challenge India confronts in promoting ambitious climate measures while also addressing its own economic growth requirements.
E. Greenwashing and the Enforcement Enigma
Environmental diplomacy faces criticism from several sources. One major worry is the possibility of "greenwashing" - when governments make overstated or deceptive statements about their environmental pledges. This situation can occur when governments agree to sign treaties or accords, but do not have the specific policies or resources necessary to effectively implement and carry out such obligations. The Greenwashing Challenge and the Need for Transparency: According to a 2022 assessment conducted by Climate Action Tracker, an independent scientific study group, India's existing climate action plans were classified as "Insufficient”. The research highlighted that although India has achieved certain advancements in the implementation of renewable energy, its dependence on coal and the absence of strong emission reduction objectives undercut its overall endeavors. This raises apprehensions over the possibility of deceptive environmental marketing practices and emphasizes the necessity for more specific strategies to convert global pledges into measurable outcomes.
F. The Enforcement Challenge and Potential Solutions
The efficacy of environmental accords is diminished by inadequate enforcement methods, such as the use of "naming and shaming," which proves ineffectual for nations lacking significant international political influence. An example of an effective deal to eliminate compounds that deplete the ozone layer is the Montreal Protocol. This agreement featured an effective system for monitoring and sanctions, which played a crucial role in its success. However, these procedures are frequently lacking in environmental accords that specifically target climate change.
IX. MOVING FORWARD: STRATEGIES FOR A MORE EFFECTIVE APPROACH
These methods can strengthen India's national environmental policy framework while preserving international collaboration, positioning it to meet its climate goals and create a future that is more environmentally friendly.
X. ENVIRONMENTAL DIPLOMACY: MAPPING A PATH TO SUSTAINABILITY
The ecological obstacles confronting our planet require a worldwide strategy. Environmental diplomacy addresses these concerns by promoting international collaboration, and its effectiveness relies on the utilization of innovative technologies, the implementation of efficient tactics, and the enforcement of robust domestic environmental rules. Now, let's explore each of these vital components in greater detail:
A. The Significance of New Technologies in Environmental Diplomacy
Emerging technologies are transforming environmental diplomacy through the provision of up-to-the-minute information on deforestation, illicit fishing, and pollution. Earth observation techniques such as LiDAR and hyperspectral photography offer precise and comprehensive information that can be used for negotiation purposes. Analysis of environmental big data facilitates the development of specific policies and proactive actions, promoting cooperation and a future that is sustainable.
B. The effectiveness of various techniques is utilized in environmental diplomacy to accomplish its goals.
The two main approaches are bilateral collaboration and multilateral cooperation. Bilateral Cooperation refers to the establishment of direct partnerships between two countries, wherein they provide customized solutions to address shared environmental concerns. India and Bhutan can cooperate in the management of shared watersheds in the Himalayas, guaranteeing long-term water management through collaborative infrastructure projects. Although bilateral agreements offer flexibility and quick execution, they may not have the same widespread influence as multinational approaches and are vulnerable to geopolitical tensions. Multilateral Cooperation refers to the collaborative efforts of multiple nations, frequently enabled by international institutions such as the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) or the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). These agreements, like the Paris Agreement or the Montreal Protocol, create worldwide standards for the environment. They provide a broader influence, more robust methods of enforcement, and the capacity to tackle worldwide concerns. India's prominent role in efforts such as the International Solar Alliance demonstrates its strong dedication to sustainable energy, exerting a significant impact on global policy. Nevertheless, achieving consensus among multiple nations can be a time-consuming process, and the enforcement of agreements may vary, contingent upon the level of political determination.
C. The Intertwined Relationship Between Domestic Regulations and Environmental Diplomacy
The efficacy of Indian environmental diplomacy is greatly impacted by the robustness of its national environmental rules. India's rigorous environmental legislation showcases its dedication to safeguarding the environment, bolstering its stance in negotiations and inspiring other countries to implement more harsh restrictions. This leadership has the potential to facilitate the development of more robust international agreements regarding the transition to sustainable energy and the exchange of knowledge. India's inadequate domestic environmental legislation may impede its environmental diplomacy endeavors, undermining its credibility in global negotiations and constraining its capacity to advocate for more stringent international environmental regulations. Implementing more stringent domestic rules has the potential to bolster India's position as a leader in environmental protection and make a positive contribution towards a healthier global ecosystem.
D. Public Diplomacy and Beyond Bilateral and Multilateral Approaches
India can employ public diplomacy strategies, such as campaigns to raise awareness, social media platforms, educational initiatives, and collaborations with non-governmental organizations, to enlighten its worldwide population about environmental concerns and promote responsible management. Citizen science efforts facilitate public engagement in environmental matters by providing tools and training programs that allow anyone to monitor the quality of water and air, track wildlife, and detect vulnerabilities related to climate change. Facilitating the growth of collaborative networks is crucial. Urban sustainability knowledge exchange is facilitated by city-to-city networks such as C40, which is Cities Climate Leadership Group. India has the ability to exchange and adopt superior methods from other countries. South-South Cooperation entails the exchange of specialized knowledge with emerging countries that are confronted with comparable difficulties. India has the capability to provide support in fields such as energy from renewable sources and sustainable agriculture, promoting unity and collaborative efforts. Collaborations with private companies are essential for the advancement of cutting-edge environmental technologies. Cooperation on renewable energy initiatives & sustainable supply chains might expedite the shift towards an environmentally friendly economy. India can make a substantial contribution to a long-term prosperity by adopting these diverse ideas. Environmental diplomacy extends beyond the relations between states and entails actively involving a wide range of stakeholders, utilizing creative techniques, and promoting a global dedication to taking action.
XI. FINDINGS AND RESULTS
This article examines the intricate relationship between India's ambitions for economic growth and its obligations towards the environment. It contends that managing this complexity and promoting India's sustainable future require environmental diplomacy.
A. Key Findings
B. Results
To summarize, India\'s economic progress is confronted with substantial environmental obstacles, requiring a careful equilibrium between advancement and sustainability. Environmental diplomacy is crucial for resolving conflicts, fostering communication, and achieving resolutions. India\'s support for incorporating environmental considerations into trade agreements demonstrates its dedication to achieving equitable economic development. The integration of environmental clauses and support for sustainable development initiatives seeks to achieve comprehensive progress. In order to address challenges effectively, India needs to bolster its domestic regulations, improve coordination of policies, and mobilize resources. Participating actively in international forums such as the Paris Agreement enhances diplomatic influence. Technological advancements provide instruments for surveillance and the formulation of policies. Public diplomacy, engagement with the private sector, and collaboration across borders improve the effectiveness of environmental diplomacy. India\'s active environmental diplomacy demonstrates its dedication to achieving balanced growth. India is striving for a sustainable and resilient future through collaborations and creative solutions.
Books [1] Vaidya, H. (2022): Environmental Diplomacy for Sustainable Development. [2] Mittal, A. & Verma, S. (2020): Balancing Growth and Climate Action: An Indian Perspective. [3] Gupta, S. (2019): India’s Climate Change Strategy: Balancing Mitigation, Adaptation, and Equity. [4] Rai, A., & Sovacool, B. (2017): Innovation for Inclusive Climate Action in India. [5] Agarwal, A., & Narain, S. (2016): Green Politics in India: Exploring the Emerging Discourse. [6] Bhagwat, R., & Somanathan, E. (2015): Indian Climate Policy: Domestic and International Dynamics. Articles [1] \"India and Climate Change: The Role of Environmental Diplomacy\" by Navroz K. Dubash (2014) [2] \"The Evolving Role of Environmental Diplomacy in India\'s Foreign Policy\" by Shruti Phadke (2018) [3] \"Challenges and Opportunities for India\'s Environmental Diplomacy\" by Kanchan Chopra (2020) Websites [1] India Brand Equity Foundation. (2023, January 19). India\'s renewable energy capacity reaches 156.9 GW. https://www.ibef.org/ [2] International Renewable Energy Agency. (2023). https://www.irena.org/ [3] Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India. (n.d.). Climate Change and India. https://www.mea.gov.in/distinguished-lectures-detail.htm?356 [4] Our World in Data. (2023). CO? emissions: different countries and historical periods. https://ourworldindata.org/co2/country/india [5] The Green Climate Fund. (n.d.). https://www.greenclimate.fund/ [6] Greenpeace East Asia. (2023, February 14). China\'s air pollution: Time for decisive action. https://www.greenpeace.org/eastasia/ [7] [^1]: The Health Effects of Fossil Fuel Air Pollution Over South Asia (2020). https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanplh/article/PIIS25425196%2822%2900090-0/fulltext [8] [^2]: Central Pollution Control Board. Water Quality Assessment https://cpcb.nic.in/water-quality-criteria/ [9] [^3]: Forest Survey of India. (2021) India State of Forest Report. https://fsi.nic.in/ [10] [^4]: World Bank. South Asia Economic Focus – Coping with Water Scarcity (2016). https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/immersivestory/2023/03/22/accelerating-change-to-solve-the-water-crisis [11] [^5]: Kumar, A., Verma, M., & Larson, B. M. (2018). Globalization and pollination disruption: Longitudinal analysis reveals declining wild pollinator service to Indian agriculture. Nature Sustainability, 1(12), 716-723. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2701761/ [12] [^6]: Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. (2022, April). The Rise of Renewables in Developing Countries: A Look at the International Solar Alliance. Retrieved from https://ieefa.org/resources/ieefa-update-developing-countries-are-disproportionately-driving-global-growth-renewables This report by IEEFA highlights the significant impact of the ISA in boosting solar energy adoption amongst member countries. The report\'s findings on the 1.5 times faster growth rate in ISA countries compared to non-members provide strong evidence for the initiative\'s effectiveness [13] [^7]: International Solar Alliance. (2022, October). One Sun Declaration. Retrieved from https://isolaralliance.org/uploads/docs/04ed5381d9e4bee207e1a1b69ad937.pdf
Copyright © 2024 Jahanvi Mishra, Dr Abhishek Verma. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Paper Id : IJRASET59049
Publish Date : 2024-03-16
ISSN : 2321-9653
Publisher Name : IJRASET
DOI Link : Click Here