Review of the Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging on Distribution Networks

Abstract

Electric vehicles (EVs) have gained significant popularity, leading to concerns about their impact on distribution networks and the integration of renewable energy sources. In response, researchers have proposed various strategies and methodologies. These include adaptive charging coordination strategies that aim to minimize the influence of EV charging on distribution networks while considering uncertainties in renewable energy generation and charging demands. Optimization- based approaches have been employed to balance loads, alleviate network congestion, and coordinate EV charging schedules with renewable energy generation and distribution network demand. The studies have also highlighted potential issues such as distribution system overloading, voltage stability problems, and the need to account for different charging infrastructure scenarios and standards. To address these challenges, control strategies integrating EV charging and battery energy storage systems (BESS) have been proposed. These strategies aim to reduce peak power demands, optimize the utilization of renewable energy sources, and shift charging loads away from peak periods. How- ever, there are still gaps to be addressed, including scalability for large-scale deployment, user convenience, and economic viability. Further research is needed to explore these areas and consider the impact of user behavior, smart grid technologies, and cost- effectiveness in accommodating EV charging and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) in residential distribution grids.

Introduction

I. INTRODUCTION

The increasing adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) has gained significant attention as a promising solution to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and decrease reliance on fossil fuels in the transportation sector [1]. This transition presents both challenges and opportunities for the electrical distribution system [3]. Effective planning and coordination are crucial for integrating EV charging into the distribution network, optimizing system operation, addressing potential issues, and maximizing the utilization of renewable energy sources.

This collection of research papers aims to understand and tackle the impact of EV charging on the distribution network. The objective of these papers is to develop innovative strategies, methodologies, and control mechanisms that optimize the charging process, relieve strain on the grid, and enhance the integration of renewable energy sources [1, 2, 3, 4]. By exploring various aspects of EV charging coordination, these studies contribute to the overarching goal of establishing a sustainable and efficient EV charging infrastructure.

The papers recognize the uncertainties associated with renewable energy generation and EV charging demands, high- lighting the need for adaptive charging strategies [4]. Several authors propose optimization-based approaches that consider the fluctuating nature of renewable energy sources and the charging flexibility of EVs [2, 3]. These strategies aim to achieve load balancing, minimize network congestion, and maximize the utilization of renewable energy. Additionally, they suggest control algorithms, monitoring systems, and forecasting techniques to optimize EV charging and battery energy storage system (BESS) operations, thereby reducing peak power demand during periods of grid constraints.

Evaluation through simulations plays a significant role in assessing the impact of EV charging on the distribution system. Authors employ simulation software to analyze system    behavior under various scenarios, such as different levels of EV penetration, charging strategies, and infrastructure considerations [4]. These studies investigate the effects of EV charging on grid parameters, including voltage profiles, power losses, transformer loading, and voltage stability. Furthermore, they explore the influence of charging patterns, user behavior, and smart grid technologies on the distribution grid to gain a comprehensive understanding of system dynamics.

While these papers offer valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities of integrating EV charging, there are certain gaps that need addressing. One aspect requiring consideration is the scalability of proposed approaches for large-scale distribution networks [4]. Real-world implementation challenges, economic feasibility, and cost-effectiveness are crucial factors that require further investigation. Addition- ally, the impact of different charging infrastructure scenarios, charging standards, and user preferences on the overall system must be explored for a holistic assessment of the EV charging ecosystem.

In conclusion, this collection of papers provides valuable insights into the field of EV charging coordination on the distribution network. Through the exploration of adaptive charging strategies, simulation studies, and considerations of system parameters, these papers contribute to ongoing efforts in achieving a sustainable and efficient EV charging infrastructure . The identified gaps underscore areas for future research, emphasizing the need for scalability, real-world implementation, economic feasibility, and user-centric approaches in the development of EV charging solutions.

II. BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT

The papers available provide valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities surrounding EV charging and its impact on distribution networks and grid infrastructure [27, 28, 29, 30]. These studies aim to address the increasing demand for EV charging while ensuring grid stability, minimizing network congestion, and optimizing the utilization of renewable energy sources. By exploring various aspects of EV charging, these papers contribute to the development of effective strategies and solutions for integrating EVs into existing power systems.

The transition to electric mobility brings both benefits and challenges. On the positive side, EVs offer reduced emissions, increased energy efficiency, and the potential to utilize renewable energy for charging purposes [27]. However, the widespread adoption of EVs presents challenges related to charging infrastructure capacity, load balancing, and its impact on distribution networks. The papers in question aim to tackle these challenges through innovative approaches and methodologies.

Several papers focus on coordination and optimization strategies for EV charging [8, 12, 15, 27]. They propose adaptive charging strategies that take into account the uncertainties of renewable energy generation, EV charging demands, and the load demands of the distribution network. These strategies seek to balance the charging load, minimize network congestion, and reduce peak power demand. They also explore the integration of BESS to shift charging load away from peak periods and make use of surplus renewable energy.

The papers also delve into evaluating the impact of EV charging on the distribution system [27, 28, 29]. Through simulations and modelling studies, researchers assess the effects on grid parameters such as voltage profiles, power losses, transformer loading, and overall system behavior. Different charging scenarios, levels of EV penetration, and charging strategies are analyzed to identify potential issues and propose mitigation measures [27, 28, 29].

Furthermore, the papers address the influence of charging patterns, user behavior, and the scalability of proposed solutions [27, 28]. The authors recognize the need to consider real- world implementation challenges, user preferences, and eco- nomic feasibility. They emphasize the importance of integrating smart grid technologies, demand response mechanisms, and considering various charging infrastructure scenarios and charging standards.

Overall, the collective body of research presented in these papers underscores the significance of addressing the challenges associated with EV charging while maximizing the benefits of electric mobility and renewable energy integration. These studies enhance our understanding of the impacts of EV charging on distribution networks and offer valuable insights for the development of efficient charging strategies, infrastructure planning, and policy-making to ensure the successful integration of EVs into existing power systems.

III. REVIEW   METHODOLOGY

The review methodology employed in the analysis of EV charging coordination and its effects on the distribution system focuses on examining multiple papers to gain insight into different aspects of the topic. The reviewed papers cover a wide range of subjects related to EV charging, including optimization strategies, system behavior analysis, load balancing, grid integration, and the utilization of renewable energy sources [1-3, 7, 12, 24].

Several papers propose optimization-based approaches to coordinate EV charging schedules with renewable energy generation and distribution network load demand. These approaches consider uncertainties related to renewable energy sources and EV charging demands in order to achieve load balancing and minimize network congestion [12, 15, 20]. Simulation-based studies utilizing software tools such as Power Factory are also common, enabling the assessment of the impact of EV charging on the distribution system.

These simulations consider different scenarios, such as varying levels of EV penetration and charging strategies, to evaluate system behavior and identify potential issues [24].

Although potential gaps in the research are identified in some papers, they include limited exploration of scalability for large-scale distribution networks, challenges associated with implementing adaptive charging strategies in real-world settings, the influence of different charging infrastructure sce- narios and standards, the effects of EV charging on voltage stability, and the consideration of smart grid technologies and demand response mechanisms to mitigate distribution system issues [4, 8, 18, 23]. Additionally, further investigation is needed into the economic feasibility and cost-effectiveness of proposed solutions, as well as the impact of user behavior and preferences [7, 8].

By analyzing multiple papers, the collective review method- ology provides a broader understanding of the challenges and opportunities related to EV charging coordination on the distribution system. It underscores the significance of considering renewable energy integration, load balancing, system stability, and the potential impact on grid parameters [ 8, 12, 15, 18, 24]. The methodologies utilized in the reviewed papers contribute to a comprehensive analysis of EV charging and offer insights for future research and practical applications.

In conclusion, the collective review methodology encompasses diverse approaches, including optimization-based strategies and simulation-based studies, to explore the coordination of EV charging on the distribution system [1-3, 7]. It identifies potential research gaps and emphasizes the need for further exploration of scalability, real-world implementation challenges, economic feasibility, user behavior, and the integration of smart grid technologies [4, 7]. The review provides valuable insights for researchers, policymakers, and industry stakeholders interested in the field of EV charging coordination and its impact on the distribution system.

IV. REVIEW ANALYSIS

The following comprehensive review analysis presents an overview of the main findings and trends observed in a range of studies focused on EV charging and its impact on the distribution system. These studies cover various aspects, including coordination strategies, system impacts, control methodologies, and grid integration. Collectively, they con- tribute to understanding the challenges and potential solutions for managing EV charging to minimize negative effects on the distribution network and maximize the utilization of renewable energy sources.

One prominent theme evident in these studies is the im- portance of adaptive charging coordination. Recognizing the uncertainties related to renewable energy generation and EV charging demands, researchers emphasize the need for strategies that can dynamically adjust charging schedules to achieve load balancing and minimize network congestion. The goal of adaptive charging coordination is to align charging patterns with renewable energy availability, ensuring optimal utilization and reducing strain on the grid during peak demand periods [12-14].

Another focus area is the evaluation of EV charging’s im- pact on the distribution system. Through simulations and analyses, researchers identify potential issues such as overloading, voltage profiles, power losses, and transformer loading. These findings emphasize the necessity of proactive measures to mitigate adverse effects, including the consideration of smart grid technologies and demand response mechanisms. Moreover, understanding different EV charging infrastructure scenarios and charging standards is crucial to account for their influence on the distribution system [22, 24, 25].

Control methodologies and strategies are extensively explored in the reviewed papers. Various approaches, such as optimization-based methods and real-time monitoring with control algorithms, are proposed to manage EV charging and leverage BESS. The aim is to reduce peak power demand, optimize renewable energy utilization, and shift charging load away from peak periods. However, further investigation is required to assess the scalability of these control strategies for large-scale deployment and their economic feasibility [9, 19, 20].

Although the papers provide valuable insights, there are specific gaps that require further investigation. Some studies lack in-depth discussions on scalability and economic feasibility, particularly in the context of large-scale distribution networks and residential grid integration. Additionally, understanding the influence of user behavior and preferences on charging patterns and considering different types of EV charging infrastructure warrant attention [7, 8, 30].

In conclusion, the review analysis of these studies underscores the significance of adaptive charging coordination, evaluation of system impacts, development of control method- ologies, and grid integration strategies. By advancing our understanding of managing EV charging, these studies facilitate optimization of the distribution system and integration of renewable energy sources. Further research is necessary to address gaps related to scalability, economic feasibility, user behavior, and diverse charging infrastructure scenarios.

Ultimately, these findings provide valuable insights for policymakers, grid operators, and researchers seeking effective strategies to promote the widespread adoption of EV while ensuring the reliability and sustainability of the distribution system.

V. DISCUSSION AND SYNTHESIS

The reviewed literature focuses on understanding how EV charging affects distribution networks. The studies cover various aspects, including coordination strategies, system be- haviour analysis, mitigation techniques, and optimization approaches. By analyzing these findings, several key themes emerge, providing insights into the challenges and opportunities associated with EV charging in distribution networks.

One significant theme is the importance of adaptive charging strategies that account for uncertainties in renewable energy generation and EV charging demands [1, 12, 14]. Optimization-based approaches are proposed to coordinate charging schedules with renewable energy sources and load demand, aiming to achieve load balancing and minimize net- work congestion [15, 16]. These strategies have the potential to enhance renewable energy integration while reducing strain on distribution networks.

The impact of EV charging on distribution systems is another critical area of study. The papers reveal potential issues related to overloading caused by EV charging through simu lations and assessments [24, 26]. To address these challenges, mitigation strategies are proposed, such as utilizing BESS and integrating smart grid technologies [19, 25]. These strategies aim to reduce peak power demand, optimize renewable energy utilization, and maintain grid stability during charging periods. However, the reviewed literature also identifies several gaps and areas for further research. These include limited discussions on scalability for large-scale distribution networks, eco- nomic feasibility of proposed solutions, and the influence of different charging infrastructure scenarios and user preferences [7, 8, 21]. Additionally, the impact of charging patterns and user behavior on grid parameters requires more attention [4,23].

Furthermore, the economic implications and cost analysis associated with accommodating EV charging in distribution grids are mentioned as potential gaps [7]. Evaluating the cost-effectiveness of proposed solutions is crucial for their widespread adoption. Factors such as infrastructure requirements, electricity pricing models, and incentives for EV users need to be considered.

Overall, the synthesis of the reviewed literature emphasizes the need for adaptive charging strategies, integration of renew- able energy sources, and addressing scalability and economic feasibility challenges. The incorporation of advanced control algorithms, demand response mechanisms, and energy storage systems emerges as key approaches to mitigate overloading, optimize renewable energy utilization, and reduce peak power demand [19, 21, 25].

In conclusion, the collective findings highlight the significance of developing adaptive charging strategies and addressing the challenges associated with EV charging in distribution networks. Future research should aim to bridge the identified gaps and explore innovative approaches to enhance the efficiency and sustainability of EV charging while ensuring the stability and reliability of distribution grids.

Conclusion

The research conducted on EV charging and its effects on distribution networks offers valuable insights and strategies to optimize EV charging, integrate renewable energy sources, and ensure grid stability. These studies emphasize the significance of adaptive charging strategies that consider the uncertainties associated with renewable energy generation and EV charging demands. By coordinating EV charging schedules with renew- able energy generation and distribution network load demand, these strategies aim to achieve load balancing and minimize network congestion. However, there are areas that require further attention. These include addressing scalability challenges for large-scale distribution networks, resolving real-world implementation is- sues, and considering various charging infrastructure scenarios and standards. Additionally, additional research is needed to comprehend the impact of different types of EV charging infrastructure, voltage stability, and the integration of smart grid technologies and demand response mechanisms. The studies also analyze the impact of EV charging on distribution systems. Simulations conducted with varying scenarios, such as different levels of EV penetration and charging strategies, help assess system behavior and identify potential overloading issues. However, it is crucial to investigate the influence of PHEV charging patterns, user behavior, and the role of smart grid technologies in ensuring grid stability and efficiency. In conclusion, these papers underscore the importance of developing adaptive charging strategies to mitigate the impact of EV charging on distribution networks. Integrating renew- able energy sources, utilizing BESS, and implementing load balancing techniques are essential for ensuring grid stability and minimizing congestion. Addressing the identified areas of improvement will contribute to overcoming scalability challenges, facilitating real-world implementation, and considering economic factors. Furthermore, exploring the impact on voltage stability, the role of smart grid technologies, and under- standing user behavior will further enhance the development of sustainable and efficient EV charging infrastructure.

References

[1] M. Soleimani and M. Kezunovic, ”Mitigating Transformer Loss of Life and Reducing the Hazard of Failure by the Smart EV Charging,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 10, no. 6, pp. 6567-6578, Nov. 2019. [2] C. Guo, D. Liu, W. Geng, C. Zhu, X. Wang, and X. Cao, ”Modeling and Analysis of Electric Vehicle Charging Load in Residential Area,” IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 199148-199161, 2020. [3] V. Aravinthan and W. Jewell, ”Controlled Electric Vehicle Charging for Mitigating Impacts on Distribution Assets,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 4697-4707, Nov. 2019. [4] L. Calearo, A. Thingvad, K. Suzuki, and M. Marinelli, ”Grid Loading Due to EV Charging Profiles Based on Pseudo-Real Driving Pattern and User Behavior,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, vol. 36, no. 1, pp. 248-257, Jan. 2021. [5] A. M. Gonc¸alves Ju´nior, H. de Paula, and W. do Couto Boaven- tura, ”Practical partial discharge pulse generation and location within transformer windings using regression models adjusted with simulated signals,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 160, pp. 330-338, Apr. 2018. [6] D. Q. Oliveira, A. C. Zambroni de Souza, and L. F. N. Delboni, ”Optimal plug-in hybrid electric vehicles recharge in distribution power systems,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 170, pp. 48-57, Feb. 2019. [7] S. Liang, B. Zhu, J. He, S. He, and M. Ma, ”A pricing strategy for electric vehicle charging in residential areas considering the uncertainty of charging time and demand,” Energy, vol. 188, 116147, Aug. 2019. [8] S. Bahrami and V. W. S. Wong, ”A Potential Game Framework for Charging PHEVs in Smart Grid,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 489-498, Jan. 2014. [9] V. T. Tran, M. R. Islam, K. M. Muttaqi, and D. Sutanto, ”An Effi- cient Energy Management Approach for a Solar-Powered EV Battery Charging Facility to Support Distribution Grids,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 1096-1106, Jul. 2018. [10] M. S. H. Nizami, M. J. Hossain, and K. Mahmud, ”A Coordinated Electric Vehicle Management System for Grid-Support Services in Residential Networks,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 4562-4572, Jul. 2019. [11] J. Tan and L. Wang, ”Integration of Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles into Residential Distribution Grid Based on Two-Layer Intelligent Op- timization,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 2025-2033, Jul. 2015. [12] J. Tan and L. Wang, ”Adequacy Assessment of Power Distribution Network with Large Fleets of PHEVs Considering Condition-Dependent Transformer Faults,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 8, no. 6, pp. 2773-2781, Nov. 2017. [13] H. Ko, T. Kim, D. Jung, and S. Pack, ”Software-Defined Electric Vehicle (EV)-to-EV Charging Framework With Mobile Aggregator,” IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 70, no. 5, pp. 4326- 4336, May 2021 [14] A. Kriukov, M. Gavrilas¸, O. Ivanov, G. Grigoras¸, B.-C. Neagu, and F. Scarlatache, ”Novel Decentralized Voltage-Centered EV Charging Control Algorithm Using DSRC System in Low Voltage Distribution Networks,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, vol. 15, no. 6, pp. 3384-3396, Jun. 2019. [15] E. Veldman and R. A. Verzijlbergh, ”Distribution Grid Impacts of Smart Electric Vehicle Charging From Different Perspectives,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 8, no. 6, pp. 2961-2970, Nov. 2017. [16] M. Bagheri Tookanlou and S. A. P. Kani, ”A comprehensive day- ahead scheduling strategy for electric vehicles operation,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 180, pp. 163-171, Mar. 2020. [17] M. S. H. Nizami, M. J. Hossain, and K. Mahmud, ”A Coordinated Electric Vehicle Management System for Grid-Support Services in Residential Networks,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 4562-4572, Jul. 2019. [18] M. S. H. Nizami, M. J. Hossain, S. Rafique, K. Mahmud, U. B. Irshad, and G. Town, ”A Multi-agent system based residential electric vehicle management system for grid-support service,” Sustainable Cities and Society, vol. 63, 102484, Jul. 2020. [19] O. Erdinc, N. G. Paterakis, T. D. P. Mendes, A. G. Bakirtzis, and J. P. S. Catala˜o, ”Smart Household Operation Considering Bi-Directional EV and ESS Utilization by Real-Time Pricing-Based DR,” IEEE Trans- actions on Smart Grid, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 2724-2733, May 2020. [20] T. Rawat and K. R. Niazi, ”Coordinated Charging of Electric Vehicles for Reducing Operation Cost under TOU Electricity Prices,” in 2018 2nd International Conference on Advances in Electrical, Electronics, Information, Communication and Bio-Informatics (AEEICB), Bangalore, India, Feb. 2018, pp. 1-5. [21] A. Clement-Nyns and E. Haesen, ”The Impact of Charging Plug-In Hybrid Electric Vehicles on a Residential Distribution Grid,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 371-380, Feb. 2010. [22] C. H. Tie, C. K. Gan, and K. A. Ibrahim, ”The Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging on a Residential Low Voltage Distribution Network in Malaysia,” in 2016 IEEE Conference on Energy Conversion (CENCON), Johor Bahru, Malaysia, Oct. 2016, pp. 1-6. [23] L. Hua, J. Wang, and C. Zhou, ”Adaptive Electric Vehicle Charging Coordination on Distribution Network,” in 2016 IEEE International Conference on Power System Technology (POWERCON), Wollongong, Australia, Oct. 2016, pp. 1-6. [24] M. Oliinyk, J. Dz?mura, and D. Pa´l, ”The Impact of Electric Vehicle Charging on the Distribution System,” in 2017 IEEE 11th International Symposium on Applied Computational Intelligence and Informatics (SACI), Timisoara, Romania, May 2017, pp. 491-496. [25] T. Simolin, A. Rautiainen, J. Koskela, and P. Ja¨rventausta, ”Control of EV Charging and BESS to Reduce Peak Powers in Domestic Real Estate,” in 2017 IEEE Nordic Circuits and Systems Conference (NORCAS): NORCHIP and International Symposium of System-on-Chip (SoC), Tallinn, Estonia, Oct. 2017, pp. 1-6. [26] K. Clement-Nyns and E. Haesen, ”The Impact of Charging Plug-In Hybrid Electric Vehicles on a Residential Distribution Grid,” in 2009 IEEE Bucharest PowerTech, Bucharest, Romania, Jun. 2009, pp. 1-7. [27] S. Vashisth, P. K. Agrawal, N. Gupta, K. R. Naizi and A. Swarnkar, ”A Novel Strategy for Electric Vehicle Home Charging to Defer Investment on Distributed Energy Resources,” 2023 IEEE IAS Global Conference on Renewable Energy and Hydrogen Technologies (GlobConHT), Male, Maldives, 2023, pp. 1-6. [28] S. Vashisth, P. K. Agrawal, N. Gupta, K. R. Naizi and A. Swarnkar, ”Integration and Co-ordinated Operation of Stationary Batteries with Fast Charging Stations,” 2022 22nd National Power Systems Conference (NPSC), New Delhi, India, 2022, pp. 560-565. [29] P. M. de Quevedo, G. Mun˜oz-Delgado and J. Contreras, ”Impact of Electric Vehicles on the Expansion Planning of Distribution Systems Considering Renewable Energy, Storage, and Charging Stations,” in IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 794-804, Jan. 2019, doi: 10.1109/TSG.2017.2752303. [30] Md Abdul Quddus, Omid Shahvari, Mohammad Marufuzzaman, John M. Usher, Raed Jaradat, A collaborative energy sharing optimization model among electric vehicle charging stations, commercial buildings, and power grid, Applied Energy, Volume 229, 2018, Pages 841-857,

Copyright

Copyright © 2023 Hari Dutt Vyas, Harsh Gautam, Mayank Jindal, Vikas Mahala. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.